BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY: Although Slumdog Millionaire is a clear-cut favorite, I think the story was too "Deus ex Machina" for my taste. I think there is a very easy link from the "Millionaire" questions to the story the Jamal is living through back flashes. Overall, it's too much of an easy happy ending for me. Now don't get me wrong, the previous years I was rooting for Juno and Little Miss Sunshine. The story's were good, but seemingly not good enough for them to become best movie, and they were both very happy ending oriented.
Frost/ Nixon is a masterful adaptation from stage to screen, but still, you can sense it was written for the stage, but no wonder this is one of the best rated movies by critics.
As for Doubt and The Reader, I think both are very good stories, but perhaps Doubt kept too much as a play (unlike Frost/Nixon which is definitely more cinematic), and Reader dwelled on a little long, more like the nove.
My favorite here is Benjamin Button, I could see a lot of similarities with Forrest Gump though, before knowing it was the same writer, maybe this will hurt it as not showing a really innovative view of things, but both Gump and Button are simply brilliant from my point of view. Also Button runs a little long, which makes me wonder how the writer was able to take so much from what originally was not a novel, but a short story, well, well, we'll see tonight.
Honorable Mention: Frost/Nixon
Bobby's Money : THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON Eric Roth
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY: The only one of the nominated movies in this category that I didn't get to see, was one for which I'm expecting a lot, since I've read good reviews on it and it actually won the Golden Globe: Happy-Go-Lucky.
Frozen River has that linear structure in a story that lately seems to have gone out of fashion but is very straight-forward and non complicated. Regular drama, not to tragic, just a good dose of harsh reality. I give this a lot of points.
Wall-E has a nice message to it, and it's clearly more like the kids version of An Inconvenient Truth, for this, I applaud it and I'm voting for it as Best Animated Feature.
In Bruges, oh, well, it is a different comedy from your usual fare, but gets too complicated into the issue of right and wrong, and the morality of it, I would put this screenplay next to The Dark Knight, but overall not in this category.
Milk, of course, as I mentioned in my review, is a no-brainer for me, this should easily win this category for its cinematic quality, for its relevance, for its timing (both on and off the screen). And, although this gets into the tragic side of drama, knowing the protagonist's fate from the beginning, it has that American Beauty (steal it) quality to it, that keeps you wanting to see the development of the story regardless of its ending.
Bobby's Money: MILK Dustin Lance Black
BEST PICTURE.
Slumdog Millionaire is a beautiful film and clearly the favorite. I have to give this one extra credit for its grand settings and the fact that it takes us through a visual bonanza of color and movement, I guess, perfectly defining Motion Pictures... Frost/ Nixon and Milk are clearly relevant to actual events in human rights, war, abuse of power.... The Reader is a wonderful love story which also addresses ignorance, (strong message), and has the Weinsteins' muscle behind it. Benjamin Button is a Dark Horse here, but I think bringing David Fincher (director: Seven, Fight Club) and Eric Roth (writer: Forrest Gump), is such a good formula that puts attention to a lot of detail and brings forth a story that actually was very compelling. Although this is handicapped a little for the fact of being a big production, I think Slumdog's recent buzz came a little after voting was closed, mmh.
Again, take into account that I lost both of the previous years nominations (Juno and Little Miss Sunshine), and actually got it right with the underdog in 2005's Crash (Buy it).
Honorable Mention: Frost/ Nixon
Bobby's Money: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON